Frankfurt '86 (album): Difference between revisions

From Allan Holdsworth Information Center
Line 66: Line 66:


https://vimeo.com/434449790
https://vimeo.com/434449790
"Here's a comparison of the original archived video & sound delivered from WDR in Germany with the remastered version released on Manifesto Records.
The video was already converted from PAL to NTSC before this comparison. The remastered audio is louder than the original audio, so take that into account when comparing the two.
The audio mastering for the DVD was independent from the mastering for the companion CD. The CD audio was mastered by Dave Schultz & Bill Inglot at d2 Mastering; the DVD audio was mastered by Greg Beaton at Tangelo Grove.
Just for the curious: Frame rate conversion, color correction & re-sizing performed in DaVinci Resolve. Audio mastering performed in Digital Performer with UA tools (mostly vintage gear emulations to enhance saturation, harmonic content, stereo soundstage and transformer-esque sonic experiences with minimal compression). File compressed for DVD in Compressor at highest possible data rate with double the data rate usually used for audio. Authored in DVD Studio Pro."


Additionally, here's an excerpt of a comment by Greg on Facebook:
Additionally, here's an excerpt of a comment by Greg on Facebook:


GB: ...with the limited budget and inability to make new cuts (add edits) on many of the transitions (because of frame rate conversion) and treat every shot separately, I felt the best choice was to globally expose for everyone’s skin (and Allan’s fretboard) and allow the highs to blow out. I kept going back and forth and I just felt it was a better compromise to portray their faces and instruments as natural - not that I feel like what I did was drastically better than the original, since it does fall short in lots of situations, but I felt that while the original was technically legal for broadcast tv, that namely their faces and Allan’s guitar were “in the dark.” I’m guessing it was a combination of not-so-great lighting and the camera technology you highlighted leaving us with a less-than-stellar luminance curve. I tried to bring only the mids up, but had to blow out the highs to keep any kind of normal contrast ratio. This of course left me with overexposed white piano keys and cymbals, but I felt like I was choosing the lesser of 2 evils, since the artists are the subjects we care most about. I also went back and forth with the black levels / setup, but ended up feeling bumping it up slightly to reveal a bit of information that was falling off too quickly to shadow was worth the compromise of noise. No noise reduction was employed.
GB: "...with the limited budget and inability to make new cuts (add edits) on many of the transitions (because of frame rate conversion) and treat every shot separately, I felt the best choice was to globally expose for everyone’s skin (and Allan’s fretboard) and allow the highs to blow out. I kept going back and forth and I just felt it was a better compromise to portray their faces and instruments as natural - not that I feel like what I did was drastically better than the original, since it does fall short in lots of situations, but I felt that while the original was technically legal for broadcast tv, that namely their faces and Allan’s guitar were “in the dark.” I’m guessing it was a combination of not-so-great lighting and the camera technology you highlighted leaving us with a less-than-stellar luminance curve. I tried to bring only the mids up, but had to blow out the highs to keep any kind of normal contrast ratio. This of course left me with overexposed white piano keys and cymbals, but I felt like I was choosing the lesser of 2 evils, since the artists are the subjects we care most about. I also went back and forth with the black levels / setup, but ended up feeling bumping it up slightly to reveal a bit of information that was falling off too quickly to shadow was worth the compromise of noise. No noise reduction was employed.
Dangerous D-Box & Focal Solo 6 Be’s used for audio monitoring; video was simply referenced to taste between a consumer Dell LED and Plasma monitor. I believe my card is a Radeon 580.
Dangerous D-Box & Focal Solo 6 Be’s used for audio monitoring; video was simply referenced to taste between a consumer Dell LED and Plasma monitor. I believe my card is a Radeon 580."


Found at https://www.facebook.com/groups/allanh/permalink/2935459816576976/
Found at https://www.facebook.com/groups/allanh/permalink/2935459816576976/